ITSRG
Connect with ITSRG
  • Contact ITSRG
  • Programs
  • People
  • News
  • Partners
  • WebMaps
  • ITSpace

The Politics of Digital Dust: South Philly Style - "with" Cell Phones

9/29/2008

4 Comments

 

ITSRG Twitter followers are no doubt aware that we have been tracking the rapidly growing Internet and Mainstream Media (MSM) story of our Graduate Fellow Michael Rovito's exchange with GOP Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin at Tony Luke's in South Philadelphia this past weekend. It seems clear from the video captured of the Rovito-Palin exchange over US strategic interests in and around Pakistan that neither she nor her handlers anticipated that folks in South Philly would have the sophistication to be concerned and conversant about their campaign's foreign policy positions.

The Rovito-Palin exchange, now infamously referred to in the blogosphere as the Cheesesteak Gaffe, is of interest to the information technology and geographic blogging communities. We noticed that the entire exchange was captured and recaptured by others in the crowd on cell phone cameras. The end of the video footage shows Governor Palin helping one of those cell phone users to verify her identity to the conversational partner with whom he was speaking. We have all done it - we see something, someone, some place of great interest and immediately pull out our mobile devices and contact members of our social network to let them in on our mini adventures and encounters through sharing stories, photos, email messages and GPS-derived locations on-the-fly. This epoch decentralization of the technologies used to stay connected with our social networks and to exchange digital information illustrates the importance of understanding not only the viral way in which information is shared, but also the proxy arrangements that are embedded within those information exchanges.

That the actual questions posed to Palin by Rovito were so quintessentially geographic in nature highlights the importance for IT and geographic educators, scholars and policy makers to come to terms with the implications of the hyper-googled earth we live on. This exchange illustrates that at any time, in any place information can be brought to bear on issues and problems in real time. The explosion of news attention to the Cheesesteak Gaffe illustrates further that the speed of traveling information often obliterates the ability to interpret context. 48 hours after the exchange, political analysts like Michael Smerconish are conducting interviews with Michael Rovito  to gain a sense of why he asked those specific questions. That George Stephanopoulos drew from the exchange of a citizen's questions directed towards Palin on This Week to probe McCain further about his policy stance on tracking terrorists between Afghanistan, Waziristan and Pakistan is a breathtaking sea change in not only how journalism is implemented but also in how information is exchanged.

This is a story that started at the grass roots and was promoted via the internet, followed by the release of video footage taken by a CNN reporter. It is precisely because of the cell phones of ordinary people being put into use to share their excitement of a rare sighting and close proximity to Palin with friends and family that the story broke before the video footage was aired. During Michael Rovito's interview with Smerconish he reveals that he did not have time to digest the meaning of her responses until after the entire exchange was concluded. Only then did he fully grasp that he caught her on the record agreeing with Obama's position on Afghanistan. The MSM storm followed the citizen use of IT, which collapsed the geographic scales, boundaries, and protocols that accompany information flows. McCain's response has been to sequester Palin once again as the only answer to controlling the speed and power of information on the ground. His campaign failed to effectively harness social media when it opted out of the use of Twitter during the primaries; and now the strategy to geographically isolate Palin fails to recognize that the electronic footprint has already kicked up crazy amounts digital dust that cannot be contained.

Michele Masucci, Director - ITSRG
Temple University

Update: 9/30/08: Related Blog posts

Last night, Katie Couric interviewed McCain and Palin, questioning them about their reaction to Rovito's questions of Palin; McCain calls Rovito a journalist involved in Gotcha politics. Then Couric reminds him that Rovito is a citizen. Here are reactions; the video of the Couric interview is embedded throughout these posts.

Read Rumproast's review of the Nguyen CNN interview of Rovito, in which she questions him twice about whether or not he engaged in "gotcha" journalism (he did not, he is a graduate student who works as a research fellow of ITSRG), here.

Michael was interviewed by CNN, see report here.

Michael was interviewed by Fox 29, see report here.

The Huffington Post discussed the gotcha comments of McCain and Palin with Couric here.

Rumproast points out that Rovito seemed more knowledgeable about current global politics than Palin. Read more here.

BL Rag also comments on the audacity of blaming a citizen for asking a direct question of a candidate; somewhat ironic given McCain's desire for town hall style debates. Read more here.

4 Comments

    RSS Feed

    ITSpace: Geographies
    of the Digital Society


    The blog zone for ITSRG - The Information Technology and Society Research Group of Temple University.

    Funded in Part by the National Science Foundation.

    Flickr BITS

    Archives

    November 2011
    February 2011
    May 2010
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009
    April 2009
    March 2009
    January 2009
    October 2008
    September 2008
    August 2008
    July 2008
    June 2008




    Website of the Month: MSPNet: Math Science Partnership Network - An Electronic Learning Community supporting NSF funded Math and Science partnership projects, sponsored by TERC.

    Previously Featured Websites
    Middle School Math Portal - Ning Network
    The Sloan Career Cornerstone

    National Science Data Library - online library for education and research in
    Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics.


    Blogroll

    Best Green Blogs
    Blbgblog
    Confused of Calcutta
    Critical Spatial Practice
    Cultural Cartography
    Digital Urban
    Disabilities Studies @ Temple
    Edu-tourism
    Eszter's Blog
    Everyday Democracy
    Farm to City
    Free Documentaries Online
    In an Ipod World
    JP: Behind the Scenes
    Juicy Geography
    Just Seeds Blog
    Making Maps
    Mapz: A GIS Librarian
    North Philly Teens
    Open Geo Data
    Phillyfuture.org
    Rolling Rains Report
    Rural Studio
    StreetsBlog
    Social Citizens Blog
    Space and Culture
    Subjective Cartography
    Sustainable Disobedience
    Temple Autism Portal
    Towards a Subjective Collective Cartography
    Transforming Learning
    Very Spatial

    Categories

    All
    Aag
    Access To Admissions
    Actionmill
    African American Experience In Philadelphia
    Alabama
    Annual Meetings Of The Association Of American Geographers
    Art Museum Of Philadelphia
    Ask Sarah Palin
    Ben Franklin Parkway
    Ben Franklin Parkway Walk
    Best Green Blogs
    Bits
    Bits 2009
    Bits And Intel
    Bits Lessons Learned
    Bits Program
    Bits Summer Program 2008
    Cartography
    Change
    Cheesesteak Exchange
    Childrens Geographies
    Citizen Cartographers
    Clinton
    Cnn
    Conversation Pods
    Cyber Safety
    Digilab
    Digital Divide
    Digital Inclusion
    Digital Mapping
    Dissemination Of Research Outcomes
    Earth Day
    Earth Day 2009
    Earthtweet
    Ecofabulous
    Ecollaboration
    Economic Crisis
    Ehealth
    Enoughfear
    Environmental Awareness
    Environmental Policy Issues
    Environments
    Ev
    Exploradelphia! BITS 2010
    Farmers Markets
    Farm To City
    Food
    Foreclosure Map
    Fow
    Fulbright
    Gasbuddy
    Gas Maps
    Gee
    General Education
    Geoforum
    Geographic Inequality
    Geographies Of Discourse
    Geographies Of The Digital Society
    Girls And Geography
    Gis And Web 20
    Google Mash Up
    Gotcha
    Gotcha Geography
    Gotcha Jouralism
    Gotcha Journalism
    Grassroots Mapping
    Green Jobs
    Greenphilly
    Greenphilly Tweetup
    Gus
    Hcc
    Hifives Program
    Historical Markers Of Pennsylvania
    Icts And Women
    Inaug
    Inauguration
    Informal Science Education
    Inside With Intel
    Intel Workshop
    Interns
    Iran
    It And Society
    Itest Lrc
    Itest Program
    Itspace
    Itsrg
    Itsrg Aag Panel Session
    Itsrg Aag Papers
    Itsrg Blog
    Itsrg Campus Visit
    Itsrg Community Programs
    Itsrg Dissemination
    Itsrg Fellows
    Itsrgorg
    Itsrg Working Papers
    Itsrg Workroom
    Itsrg Workshop
    Itsrg Works With Intel
    Journalism Map
    Landscape
    Landscape Analyisis
    Legendary Blue Horizon
    Lime
    Live Blogging
    Los Angeles
    Love Park
    Maps
    Maps In The News
    Mccain
    Metro Engagement Forum
    Michael Rovito
    Milk Map
    National Parking Day
    News
    No Impact Map
    North Philadelphia
    Obama
    Open Street Maps
    Pa
    Palin
    Parking Day
    Parking Geographies
    Phennd
    Philadelphia
    Philadelphia Environmental Issues
    Philadelphia Work Ready
    Photodocumentation
    Photo Documentation
    Policy Space
    Presidential Campaign
    Presidential Inauguration
    Presidential Politics
    Progress Plaza
    Pyn
    Quantitative Literacy
    Reflections On Parking Day
    Resource Links
    Route Maps
    Rovito
    San Diego Fire Map
    Sarah Palin
    Sheppard School Project
    Showcase Event
    Shro
    Social Media
    Srop Program
    Student Bloggers
    Student Research
    Summer Work Ready
    Sustainable Disobedience
    Swig
    Tartaglione
    Telemedicine
    Telemedicine And Women
    Telemedicine In Philadelphia
    Temple
    Temple University
    The Huffington Post
    Theorizing The Digital Divide
    Tweetup
    Twitter
    Twitter And Presidential Politics
    Twitter Wars
    Usercontent
    Visual Methods
    Web 20
    Webinar
    Wikimapia
    Wilcox County
    Wissahickon Park
    Women And Ehealth
    Write Now In May
    Yelp
    Zopif

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.